Search
Carlisle Fishing Reports
Change View:
By: Anonymous
Posted: 7/28/1999
Species:
Rating: 5
Fished: 7/28/1999
Hot Spots: 0
Great Fishing! I got a few steelhead, and 3 BIG rainbow, they were about 17 inches. And all of this in 3 hours!!!
By: Anonymous
Posted: 4/27/2002
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 4
Fished: 4/27/2002
Hot Spots: 0
When to Carlisle opening day, caught and released about a dozen trout from 8-12 inches, 11 inches being the norm. Used roster tails and brightly colored spoons. Most people on the lake did well, those...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 4/28/2002
Species:
Rating: 5
Fished: 4/28/2002
Hot Spots: 0
I went to Carlisle, Plummers, and Borst lake opening day, and Carlisle was by far the best of the three. I was there from about noon to four and caught and released about fifteen 6-11 inch rainbows, I...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 4/29/2002
Species:
Rating: 4
Fished: 4/29/2002
Hot Spots: 0
Tyler and I had such a grand time opening day we decided to go back the next day. We were there from about noon to a quarter to three. Got a ton of hits on red/white striped spoons, only landed seven ...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 8/25/2002
Species:
Rating: 2
Fished: 8/25/2002
Hot Spots: 0
Fished Carlisle from about 3:00-6:30pm. I caught and threw back two 6 inch rainbows and my friend caught and released another mini-bow of the same size. All were caught on rooster tails. No one was do...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 4/24/2004
Species:
Rating: 5
Fished: 4/24/2004
Hot Spots: 0
Fished at this shallow old mill pond on opening day. Lake is full of stocked trout of smaller size. Fast action creep trolling a size 12 black nymph just under the surface and also on dry flies at dus...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 6/8/2005
Species:
Rating: 1
Fished: 6/6/2005
Hot Spots: 0
I fished at Carlise from 10:15am until 2:30pm and got some bites using a bobber with
worms and powerbait and ended up skunked for the day bye.
By: Anonymous
Posted: 4/29/2006
Species:
Rating: 4
Fished: 4/29/2006
Hot Spots: 0
Great opener! arrived at 6 am stayed till about noon - when i limited. fish were average of 10-12 inches, however I saw some nice 15-17 inchers coming out of the water every once in a while. There w...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 5/22/2006
Species:
Rating: 4
Fished: 5/20/2006
Hot Spots: 0
Got down there about 3pm for some afternoon fishing. Asked some other anglers how they were doing and the consistant reply was, "no bites, no fish." I asked an old-timer on the lake what to fish with ...
By: leahcim_dahc
Posted: 10/14/2007
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 3
Fished: 10/14/2007
Hot Spots: 0
Arrived at Carlisle at about 930 am, air temperature was about 50-55F, scattered high clouds. Never fished this lake before so wasn't sure what was going to bite. Walked part way around the lake casti...
By: dawgdrvr
Posted: 1/25/2008
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 3
Fished: 1/24/2008
Hot Spots: 0
I arrived at the lake about 0730 yesterday the 24th of Jan 08. I had read on the WDFW that they planted 50 or so 6.5 pounders in the lake on the 11th. It was bitter cold about 28* . T he lake was tota...
By: Fish-or-man?
Posted: 4/27/2008
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 4
Fished: 4/26/2008
Hot Spots: 0
I fished Carlisle Lake opening day from 1:30 to 4:30 pm. I only landed four, but three of the four were triploids. The lake was extremely crowded on the side that the boat launch/parking lot/school is...
By: Jacob
Posted: 4/28/2008
Species: Largemouth Bass
Rating: 5
Fished: 4/28/2008
Hot Spots: 0
Me and a buddy of mine took the pontoons to Carlisle today to catch some trout. We got there around 10:00 and I decided to try for bass for a while. I fished for about 30 yards past the boat launch an...
By: lemagoat
Posted: 5/3/2008
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 3
Fished: 5/2/2008
Hot Spots: 0
Took my son out to the old mill pond to catch some planter trout, used bobber and worms mostly and some spinners, powerbait on the bottom, caught a lot of 8-10 inchers were releasing all fish. Son wan...
By: leahcim_dahc
Posted: 5/11/2008
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 3
Fished: 5/11/2008
Hot Spots: 0
Late start waiting for the kiddies. Arrived at Carlisle around noon. Wind was from the southwest at about 10mph. Water temperature was 56 F.
Offloaded the 'toon and motored around the lake to do se...
By: Anonymous
Posted: 7/27/2008
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 4
Fished: 7/27/2008
Hot Spots: 0
me and my girlfriend hit the lake at about 6 am this morning and had nothing but bites. If you are quick enough you can catch them, we left at 10:30am and had 3 keepers 2 10" and 1 8". So all in all...
By: fishtremble
Posted: 1/13/2009
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 1
Fished: 1/13/2009
Hot Spots: 0
I started about 3:15 in the afternoon. No one else was there fishing. The weather was overcast, with a light wind. The level of the lake was highest I have ever seen it. I tried several spots from...
By: Jake Dogfish
Posted: 1/20/2009
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 3
Fished: 1/19/2009
Hot Spots: 0
Yes I know its been awhile since I posted a report.
I tried Carlisle for the first time from the shore. The weather was great, and I had heard of recent broodstock plants. The bait was power e...
By: dawgdrvr
Posted: 5/26/2009
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 4
Fished: 5/25/2009
Hot Spots: 0
Arrived at 6:30 am. to mist on the lake. Way cool. Started out using an 1/8 oz home made inline spinner (Panther Martin type). caught & released 10 or 12 planter trout by 10: am. when the sun came ou...
By: Fish-or-man?
Posted: 4/28/2012
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 4
Fished: 4/28/2012
Hot Spots: 0
My buddy and I fished Carlisle Lake from about 10-1. Caught and released 15-20 trout a piece on spinners (barbless single hook). A lot of small fish. Really small, like 4-5 inches. But there were some...
By: chris_brown
Posted: 6/19/2012
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 5
Fished: 6/3/2012
Hot Spots: 1
Hit carlisle lake on sunday, tried for bass for a bit but had no luck, switched up to trout so I could at least catch some fish before I went home. Caught plenty, third fish was a 7 pound lunker. Coup...
By: fishtremble
Posted: 12/9/2012
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 2
Fished: 12/8/2012
Hot Spots: 0
I tried some fishing at Carlisle Lake, for a few of hours. It was overcast, with a little rain. The fishing calendar rated it a poor day. I got there at about 2:45. There weren't any other people ...
By: Fish-or-man?
Posted: 5/8/2013
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 3
Fished: 5/5/2013
Hot Spots: 0
I've done poorly my last two fishing trips, so after work Monday I decided I need to feel a pull at the other end of the line. I headed down to Carlisle Lake to catch and release some stocked trout. I...
By: fishtremble
Posted: 6/28/2013
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 5
Fished: 6/27/2013
Hot Spots: 0
I did some fishing at Carlisle Lake. It was overcast and warm, with a little wind. The fishing calendar rated it a good day. I got there at 7:00 in the evening. I counted about 8 other people fish...
By: fishtremble
Posted: 7/8/2013
Species: Rainbow Trout
Rating: 4
Fished: 7/6/2013
Hot Spots: 0
I tried some fishing at Carlisle Lake. It was clear and warm, with a little wind blowing. The fishing calendar rated it a poor day. I got a late start and got there at 8:30 in the evening. I count...
